Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
decentralization · Implications of the end-to-end principle
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Show off your group to the world. Share a photo of your group with us.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Microsoft improves SmartTag feature (let's get back to Decentrali z   Topic List   < Prev Topic  |  Next Topic >
Reply | Forward < Prev Message  | 
Microsoft has just told me that they are changing the SmartTags feature to
respond to our criticism. Below is the note I just received. I'll reserve
the right to look at the final implementation before I announce that this
feature is totally good, but at least we can go back to discussing
Decentralization technologies.

Is the Stutz "interview" dead?

+++++

I'm a developer for IE, not responsible for smart tags, but I know what's
going on.

Because of the -- and there's no better word for it, we're shocked --
uproar, the following changes are going to be made:
1. smart tags off by default (they were on by default to exercise the code,
get Watson crashes)
2. the user-overrides-authored-meta-tag option removed
3. no recognizers shipping in box. So until you do have a recognizer
installed, when you click on the smart tag button, you get navigated to a
gallery from which you can download desired recognizers.

Will that make you happy? Probably not. But that's the current state of the
feature.

If you choose to mention this prior to the release in the public builds --
2497+ should have the changes -- please don't identify me other than "a
source".



Sun Jun 17, 2001 3:23 am

rscoble@...
Send Email Send Email

Forward
< Prev Message  | 
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Microsoft has just told me that they are changing the SmartTags feature to respond to our criticism. Below is the note I just received. I'll reserve the right...
Robert Scoble
rscoble@...
Send Email
Jun 17, 2001
3:23 am

Hi Guys Glad I read this. Normally support MS on most issues, simply because i realise thay are not real isssues. Smart Tags was becoming a real one, I...
apwizard@...
Send Email
Jun 17, 2001
7:59 am

... This is the big one for you, right, Robert (as long as it's implemented properly)? The fact that publishers did not have the power to disable user's smart...
allenjs@...
Send Email
Jun 17, 2001
3:13 pm

... Both you and mr Scoble's source at MS deemed it necessary to point out that you have been clueless (and wrong) about the reception of this feature. That is...
beno@...
Send Email
Jun 18, 2001
3:24 pm

... could ... Agreed. It could have been implemented as a web application using a proxy server, or (more simply) framing. A few more thoughts.. I would have...
Dave Winer
dave@...
Send Email
Jun 18, 2001
3:49 pm

... You underestimate the power of your opponents in shaping people's opinions. I can not believe the naivate of your company. You're all supposed to be so...
kiyoumars@...
Send Email
Jun 18, 2001
4:07 pm

Josh I think you'd better talk to these people too. http://public.wsj.com/sn/y/SB991862595554629527.html ...
Dave Winer
dave@...
Send Email
Jun 17, 2001
5:48 pm

I had seen the WSJ one; thanks for the links. These are some interesting issues that I think society will continue to debate; hopefully without me or any...
allenjs@...
Send Email
Jun 17, 2001
6:38 pm

Please tell your Microsoft source to not cave in to baseless criticism. Simply open the protocol and allow users to specify the Server providing the meta-info...
kiyoumars@...
Send Email
Jun 17, 2001
11:55 pm

... I completely agree, but I wouldn't go around calling people clueless because they disagree with you....
Erik Moore
esmoore@...
Send Email
Jun 18, 2001
4:31 pm

... clueless because they disagree with you. And I agree with you, and I quote Mr. Allen who himself wrote that "[they] had no clue". That's clueless, right? ...
kiyoumars@...
Send Email
Jun 18, 2001
4:36 pm

Howdy. It's SmartTag Time! And the X-link devil is out of the bag. What a show!!! I can't keep up. But there is one question I'd like to ask before I venture...
Adrian Harvey
aharvey@...
Send Email
Jun 21, 2001
3:59 pm

... I don't see how you could accurately say that. A SmartTagged document does not have to be marked up in XHTML, and the choice to implement static smart tags...
Erik Moore
esmoore@...
Send Email
Jun 21, 2001
5:16 pm

... Well, suppose you wanted a recognizer to recognize based on text selections that your friends had marked. It is true that recognizers based off of words...
allenjs@...
Send Email
Jun 21, 2001
6:54 pm

... <root> <subject>This is a news message</subject> <message>But that doesn't mean NNTP is an implementation of XML</message> </root> I didn't mean to imply...
Erik Moore
esmoore@...
Send Email
Jun 21, 2001
7:00 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help